Request a Same Day Telephone Consultation
Is your worker an employee or independent contractor?
If a worker is classified as an independent contractor, the employer is not required to withhold or pay Social Security and Medicare (FICA), State and Federal income taxes, unemployment insurance taxes (FUTA), workers' compensation, overtime, or a host of other benefits. If a worker is properly classified as an independent contractor, the employer is also free from a myriad of onerous legal obligations pertaining to California's wage and hour laws, anti-discrimination laws, state and federal OSHA (safety) regulations, etc. In an effort to avoid these responsibilities, many employers try to classify their workers as independent contractors. The problem is…if an employee is misclassified as an "independent contractor," the employer is potentially liable for such things as:
It should also be noted that pursuant to California case law, the existence of a written agreement stating that the worker is an independent contractor is not determinative, nor is the fact that that the worker was issued a 1099. See, S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v Dept. of Industrial Relations, 48 Cal.3d 341 (1989) and Toyota Motor Sales v. Superior Court, 220 Cal.App.3d 864, 877 (1990).
So what determines if a worker is an employee versus independent contractor?
Unfortunately, in California it is very difficult to determine if a worker is an employee or independent contactor because the IRS and each state agency applies its own set of factors to make the determination. It is therefore possible for one agency to classify a worker as an employee and for another to determine that the same worker is an independent contractor. In addition to the IRS, the state agencies most involved with the determination of whether a worker is an employee vs. independent contractor are: the Employment Development Department (EDD), the Division of Labor Standards and Enforcement (DLSE), the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), the Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC), and the Contractors State Licensing Board (CSLB).
Despite the multitude of tests, each of which is examined below, in general, a worker is appropriately classified as an independent contractor if:
The remainder of this article will set forth how the DLSE, the EDD, and the IRS each determine whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor.
The DLSE and EDD Both Use The Economic Realities Test to Determine if a Worker is an Employee or Independent Contractor.
The DLSE, which is concerned with whether the employer has followed California's wage, hour and workers' compensation laws, starts with the presumption that the worker is an employee. See, California Labor Code §3357. The DLSE then applies California's "5 Pronged Economic Realities Test" adopted by the California Supreme Court in S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v Dept. of Industrial Relations, 48 Cal.3d 341 (1989). Under this multi-factor test, the most significant factor is whether the employer has control, or the right to control, the worker and the manner and means by which the work is performed. Additional factors include:
Under the DLSE's Multi-Factor Test, even where the adjudicating officer determines there is an absence of control over work details, the DLSE will find an employer-employee relationship if: (1) the alleged employer retained pervasive control over the operation as a whole, (2) the worker’s duties were an integral part of the business owner's operation, and (3) the nature of the work makes detailed control unnecessary. See, Yellow Cab Cooperative v. Workers Compensation Appeals Board, 226 Cal.App.3d 1288 (1991).
The EDD Uses the "Control Test" to Determine if a Worker is an Employee or Independent Contractor.
To determine whether a worker is an employee or independent contractor, the EDD uses the "Control Test" pursuant to which an individual is an employee if: (1) the law defines the worker as an employee (statutory employee) or (2) the employer has the right to exercise control over the manner and means by which the worker performs his/her services (common law employee). See, Independent Contractor Misconceptions published by the EDD. For the EDD, the right to discharge a worker at will and without cause is strong evidence of the right of direction and control. Other factors that support a finding of the right to control (which are similar to those used by the DLSE) include:
The IRS uses a new 11 Factor Test to Determine if a Worker is an Employee or Independent Contractor.
The IRS will weigh and balance 11 factors in three groups (behavioral control, financial control, and the parties' relationship) to determine if an independent contractor should be reclassified as an employee.
The Behavioral Control Test seeks to determine whether there is a right to direct or control how the worker does the work. If the IRS determines that there is extensive control, the worker will be classified as an employee. If a worker is told when, where, how and whether to work, the IRS will likely find extensive control and classify the worker as an employee. According to the IRS, the following are examples of types of instructions about how to do work:
The Financial Control Test. If the alleged employer has the ability to control the business aspects of the worker's job, the IRS is more likely to find an employer-employee relationship. Under the Financial Control Test, the IRS will look at the following 5 factors:
The Type of Relationship Test. The IRS will then look at the type of relationship that existed between the owner and the worker, such as:
Although each of the test's balance and weigh different factors, it typically comes down to what we said in the introduction. In general, a worker is appropriately classified as an independent contractor if:
California employers should err on the side of caution and if in doubt classify the worker as an employee.
Our employment law practice consists of: (1) assisting employees with their contracts and wage claims and (2) counseling employers who seek to comply with new state and federal employment laws, providing human resource training, and providing essential contracts and employee policies to prevent employee lawsuits. To schedule a consultation call 818-849-5206 or Send Us An Email and California Employment Law Attorney Melissa C. Marsh will see if she can assist you.
California employment lawyer, Melissa C. Marsh, is based in Sherman Oaks and West Hollywood, and serves individuals throughout Los Angeles County, including: West Hollywood, Miracle Mile, Beverly Hills, Century City, Santa Monica, Burbank, North Hollywood, Valley Village, Toluca Lake, Studio City, Sherman Oaks, Van Nuys, Encino, and Woodland Hills.
© 2008 - 2011 Melissa C. Marsh. All Rights Reserved.
Disclaimer: The information presented on this web site was prepared by Melissa C. Marsh for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The information provided in my articles and alerts should not be relied upon, or used as a substitute for professional legal advice from an attorney you retain to advise or represent you. Your use of this Internet site does not create an attorney- client relationship. Transmission of this article is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. All uses of the contents of this site, other than personal uses, are prohibited. You may print or email a copy of any information posted on this web site for your own personal, non-commercial, use, but you may not publish any of the articles or posts on this web site without the Express Written Permission of Melissa C. Marsh.
Located in Los Angeles, California, the Law Office of Melissa C. Marsh handles business law and corporation law matters as a lawyer for clients throughout Los Angeles including Burbank, Sherman Oaks, Studio City, Valley Village, North Hollywood, Woodland Hills, Hollywood, West LA as well as Riverside County, San Fernando, Ventura County, and Santa Clarita. Attorney Melissa C. Marsh has considerable experience handling business matters both nationally and internationally. We routinely assist our clients with incorporation, forming a California corporation, forming a California llc, partnership, annual minutes, shareholder meetings, director meetings, getting a taxpayer ID number (EIN), buying a business, selling a business, commercial lease review, employee disputes, independent contractors, construction, and personal matters such as preparing a will, living trust, power of attorney, health care directive, and more.